Monthly Review - Stem Cells
Scott, Christofer T. STEM CELL NOW. New York: Plume, 2006. An introduction into the
coming medical revolution offers a brief history of embryonic stem cells and the resulting
moral and political issues that have been raised.
In 1998, James Thompson reported the development of the first line of human stem cells
with a typical scientific understatement, "These cell lines should be useful in human devel-
opmental biology, drug discovery, and transplantational medicine," There are currently
two methods of developing stem cell lines. Human embryonic stem cell(HESC) lines arise
from the inner mass of stem cells in a blastocyst(a fertilized egg that has divided into circa
200 cells). This cell mass is cultured in a controlled environment that allows indefinite pro-
liferation of cloned copies of the stem cells, thereby establishing a stem cell line. The work
of J. Thompson was an HESC line. The second method fuses a cell from donor tissue with
an egg that has had its nucleus excised. Cell division then occurs and the resulting blast-
ocyst is used as a surrogate embryo. This method is referred to as somatic cell nuclear
transfer(SCNT). The cloning of Dolly used SCNT; an egg from a donor sheep with an excis-
ed nucleus was fused with a cell from another sheep and the resulting blastocyst was im-
planted in the uterus of a surrogate ewe.
The initial stem cells in a blastocyst have the potential to form any cell type in the body.
As an embryo develops, cells differentiate in steps as they follow maturation paths. Once a
stem cell reaches the end of a path it is no longer able to divide and is terminally differen-
tiated. Eventually It ages and dies and is replaced by a new terminal cell. Skin, muscle,
and blood cells are examples of terminal cells. Because of this replacement system, stem
cells necessarily exhibit an asymmetric cell division. One daughter cell is an exact copy
and the other one is more specialized and more restricted in the ability to differentiate. A
supply of stem cells is maintained and replacement cells are generated by asymmetric
division. Several hundred million skin cells are replaced every day by this mechanism.
Stem cells are distributed in a mature organism in numerous areas termed niches that pro-
vide repair and regeration of major sytems such as the liver, skin, muscles, etc. The stem
cells providing rerpair and regeneration are termed adult stem cells.
Starting with the seeming magic of a single cell developing into a fully functioning organ-
ism, the author covers the history of researching stem cells and the attempt to understand
the development of an organism. This reserach is now at a point where promise of future
medical practice that goes from regenerating lost functions to regeneration of complete or-
gans has raised both hope and a sense of urgency. As Christopher Reeves, the quadriple-
gic actor put it, "I want things to happen quickly. I don't want to get out of this wheel chair
at the age of 75. I am not willing to to resign myself to being an advocate for research that
will benefit people only after I'm gone. I'm not that noble." Unfortunately he died in 2004
at age 52. Both patients and their families are asking, "Will there be a cure? And will it
be in time for us?" Unfortunately biological reality has been overshadowed by the many
promises that are being given. The author lists seven questions that must be answered be-
fore any clinical procedures can be forthcoming. The concensus among scietists is that re-
search must first focus on the many small pieces of a large picture before cures of diseases
and disabilities are developed that have been promised to the public.
In the meantime, a controversy of a political and theological nature has erupted that has
gone so far that the new field of bioethics has emerged solely to study the impact on hu-
manity of advances in medicine and technology. The intensity of this controversy is best
illustrated by two quotations, "The newly fertilized egg, a corpuscle one two-hundreth of
an inch in diameter is not a human being. It is a set of instructions set adrift in the womb",
and, "We will, slowly and by increments, have gone from stem cells to embryo farms to
fetuses hanging(metaphorically) on meat hooks waiting to be cut open and used by the
already born." Scott details theological arguments advanced by major religions and tech-
nical arguments raised by leading scientists. He also details the political history of stem-
cell research and the four-year moratorium that was imposed. All of these arguments, how-
ever, beg a far more fundamental question. What justification supports sacrificing the few
for the benefit of the many? During the second world war, the United States infected con-
sciencetious objectors with malaria in a program to develop chloroquine. At the same time
Germany sacrificed prisoners in studying physiological effects of seat ejection and high-alt-
tude. The former project was based on the expediency of protecting American soldiers in
the Pacific. The latter, although condemned, did not deter the U. S. from acquiring German
data and also recruiting the chief flight surgeon of the Luftwaffe under operation paper-clip,
the same program that brought Werner von Braun to the U.S. It is doubtful that the reconcil-
iation of stem-cell research will be as clear cut or as simple as many people currently hope.
References for Stress
Selye, H. The Stress of Life. New York: Harper & Row, 1956, 1976. The nonspecific reac-
tion of the body to any demand imposed upon it, and the roles the central nervous system
and the endocrtine system play in this response form the basis of the research of H. Selye.
This nonspecific response to any demand is the essence of Dr. Selye's theory of stress.
Selye, H. Stress Without Distress. New York: Harper & Row, 1974. Develops a code of
behavior based on immutable natural laws to successfully cope with stress. In developing
this code, Dr. Selye relates topics such as work and leisure, motivation, and life style to the
management of stress without distress.
Shiraldi, G. R. Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. Lincolnwood, IL: Lowell House, 2000.
Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) exemplifies the theory of stress of H. Selye. Follow-
ing the Vietnam war, the American Psychaiatrtic Association identified PTSD as an anxiety
disorder caused by traumatic stress. Subsequent clinical research developed a method of
treatment, and this hanbook details the current procedures employed in treating PTSD.
References for Nutrition
Quillin, P. Healing Nutrients. New York: Random House, 1989. Develops a program for
optimal nutrition and indicates modifications and add-ons that address prevention specific
to disease resistance and wound healing, allergies, and healthy aging. The basic premise
is that optimal nutrition can provide better health to nearly everyone.
Garcia, O. The Balance. New York: HarperCollins, 2000. Develops a nutritional regimen
based on metabolic types of slow, fast and hybrid oxidizers. The development is also based
on differences between modern and primitive diets, and modern and primitive social orga-
nizations. The development is structured for use by a nutritionist offering consultation to a
specific client; it includes a subjective test to determine metabolic type.
Challem, J. Syndrome X. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 2000. Syndrome X is a group
of symptoms stemming from excessive consumption of refined carbohydrates. Obesity, high
blood pressure. hardening of arteries, insulin resistance, and diabetes are all part of syn-
drome X. A diet is designed that eliminates refined carbohydrates and has five times the a-
mount of vegetables as in an average American diet. The diet also emphasizes foods of
low and moderate glycemic indices (the rate of glucose entry into the bloodstream).
Weil, A. Healthy Aging. New York: Random House, 2005. Aging and death are accept-
ed as inevitable. However, aging with good health and maintaining effective energy levels
is not only felt to be desireable, but also attainable. A holistic approach that includes diet,
supplements, life style, and environment is advanced. The objective is to age gracefully.
Mizrahi, A. Bee Products. New York: Plenum Press, 1996. A conference was held
in Tel Aviv, Israel on bee products: properties, applications, and apitherapy. Bee products
include honey, royal jelly, persopolis, and bee pollen. In addition, the conference included
results using bee venom as a therpeutic agent.
References for Supplements
The references that follow deal specifically with supplements for antioxidants, enzymes,
and proteins. The reference "Healthy Aging" above has an excellent summary of the ingre-
ients required for an effective multi-vitamin and multi-mineral supplement.
Balch, J. F. The Super Oxidants. New York: M. Evans & Company, 1998. Lists upwards
of 125 fruits and vegetables and the types and amounts of antioxidants they provide. Also
listed are commercial supplements such as co-enzyme Q10 and plant extracts from garlic,
ginseng, etc.
Lee, L. The Enzyme Cure.Tiburon,CA: Alternative Medicine,1998. Identifies three types
of enzymes, metabolic, pancreatic, and plant. Listed are formulations of enzyme supple-
ments specific to problems such as food allergies, digestion problems, cardiovascular prob-
lems, etc. Also included is a formulation for people in good health who want a single natu-
ral supplement for maintenance.
Evans, G. Chromium Picolinate. Honesdale, PA: Paragon Press, 1996. Discusses Chrom-
ium picolinate and its relation to carbohydrate and fat metabolism and the maintenance
of muscle mass.
Natow, A. B. The Protein Counter. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2003. A handbook
listing the protein, fat, and carbohydrate components of numerous foods and branded food
products. Also included are lists of protein and amino-acid supplements.
References for Therapies
All of the references in the sections for nutrition and supplements include material on ther-
apy by indicating the general salutary nature of a nutritous diet. The references that follow
are specific programs that are designed to restore and maintain good health.
Edelson, S. P. Autoimmune Disorders. New York: Warner Books, 2003. Discusses the
nature of autoimmune diseases and establishes a treatment in three phases for curing
these diseases; viz. detoxification, replenishment, and maintenance of homeostasis.
Hertoge, T. Hormone Solution. New York: Harmony Books, 2002. Natural hormones
are combined with nutrition to promote health and longevity. The course of treatment goes
far beyond the classical therapy for hypothyroidism and diabetes. It should be noted that
the imperative to obtain advice and treatment from a health professional for a program of
this nature is not emphasized as much as it should be.
Sears B. Omega Rx Zone. New York: Harper Collins, 2003. The Omega Rx zone refers
to a hormonal balance that supports optimal health and promotes longevity. A diet is pro-
posed that is based on two factors: a balance of carbohydrates and proteins at every meal
to control insulin levels, and fat intake based primarily on fish oil of pharmaceutical-grade
purity. A theory is advanced that this diet corresponds to the one mankind ate during the
last stages of evolution.
Cliunic, Mayo The Mayo Clinic Plan. New York: Time Inc., 2006. A program consisting
of ten steps that focuses on fitness, diet, and weight. Also included are issues of life style
such as tobacco, social connections, stress, rest and relaxation, and safety issues.
References for the Environment
Shnayerson, M. The Killers Within. New York: Little, Brown and Company, 2002. The
rise of drug-resistant bacteria have evolved to the point where medical personnel are at
an impasse in seeking effective treatment of infections, especially for staphylococci. A
note of optimism is sounded with a discussion of current research into the use of peptides
and bacteriophages as antibiotics.
Colborn, T. Our Stolen Future. New York: Penguin Books, 1997. The emerging scien-
fific evidence of the disruption of hormonal balances caused by man-made chemicals is
detailed for several ecological systems. Evidence is mounting that the fertility, healthy de-
velopment, and even survival of mankind are threatened.
Smith, J. M. Seeds of Deception. White River Junction, VT: Chelsea Green, 2003. An
alarm is raised that genetic modification of plants may produce dramatically unexpected
results beyond the objective of the modification. Surprises from genetic modification range
from abnormal depletion of nutritional value to the creation of fatal toxins.
References of General Interest
Venes, D. Taber's Cyclopedic Medical Dictionary. Philadelphia: F. A. Davis Co., 2001.
Taber's is a comprehensive resource that goes far beyond being a medical dictionary. It
includes disease entries with symptoms, diagnosis and treatment, policies for safe health
care, nutritional information, nursing practices, tables that list information such as normal
reference lab values, and a potpourri of other general information. Taber's has published
twenty editions with over six million copies sold.
Widmaier, E. P. The Stuff of Life. New York: Henry Holt and Company, 2002. Discusses
the interplay of tissue, blood, hormones, enzymes, fats, sugars, and minerals that produces
a living organism. Along the way, questions such as how food is digested, how brain chem-
istry influences behavior, and what the differences in fats and proteins mean to health are
addressed.
Schauss, A. G. Minerals, Trace Elements and Health. Tacoma, WA: Biosocial Publica-
tions, 1999. Estmates the optimal level of intake for twenty-one minerals ranging from
Beryllium to Zinc. Toxicic levels of non-essential elements such as lead are also discussed.